Sure, he was clearly manipulative, but did the Mirror actually lie the one time they talked for sure? He gave Jay information, albeit cryptic, potentially dangerous information.

Jay agrees with Tim on one thing, though. He's definitely a dick.

"I guess we can't exactly..." Jay pinches the bridge of his nose. "...prove it for sure either way."

He rocks back, leaning his head against the wall. "So if it was him, then what? What would he even gain from that?"